Here’s a guide to help you with vintage toy appraisal.
Understanding Vintage Toys #
Vintage toys are playthings from previous decades, often reflecting the culture and technology of their time.
They range from early 20th-century tin toys to 1980s action figures. Collectors cherish them for their historical significance, craftsmanship, and the memories they evoke.
Key Factors in Appraisal
Age: Older toys, especially those from the early to mid-20th century, are typically more valuable due to their rarity.
Condition: A toy in mint condition, free from damage and with its original packaging, can fetch a higher price. Even minor wear can significantly impact value.
Rarity: Limited editions, prototypes, or toys that had a short production run are often more sought after.
Demand: Toys from popular franchises or those that have a dedicated collector base tend to be more valuable.
Steps to Appraise Your Vintage Toys #
Research: Start by identifying your toy’s make, model, and year. Use online databases, collector forums, and reference books to gather information.
Condition Assessment: Examine the toy for any signs of wear, missing parts, or repairs. Note if the original packaging is present and its condition.
Consult Price Guides: Reference current price guides or online auction sites to see what similar toys are selling for.
Seek Expert Opinion: For high-value items, consider getting a professional appraisal from a reputable dealer or appraiser.
Preserving Your Collection #
To maintain the value of your vintage toys:
Proper Storage: Keep toys in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.
Handling: Minimise handling to prevent wear and use gloves if necessary.
Cleaning: Clean gently with appropriate materials; avoid harsh chemicals.
Appraising vintage toys requires a blend of research, attention to detail, and sometimes expert advice.
Reselling Vintage Toys #
Identify Your Audience:
Research who collects the type of toy you’re selling. Different toys appeal to different buyers—1980s action figures may draw nostalgia-focused collectors, while tin toys attract those seeking rarer, older pieces.
Choose the Right Platform:
Sell on platforms like eBay for a global audience, or use niche websites, collector forums, or auction houses for rare and valuable items. Local toy fairs and social media groups can also connect you with buyers.
Time Your Sale:
Align sales with trends or anniversaries. For example, a movie re-release or franchise revival can increase demand for related toys.
Price Strategically:
Check recent sales on platforms like eBay or use vintage toy price guides to set your price. Rare or mint-condition items might warrant a professional appraisal to ensure accuracy.
Account for Fees and Costs:
Factor in platform fees, shipping, and any additional costs when setting your price to ensure profitability.
Present Your Toy Well:
Take clear photos from multiple angles, highlight any unique features, and include details about its condition. Be transparent about any flaws to build buyer trust.
Network with Collectors:
Build relationships with collectors and dealers through fairs, forums, or social groups to access potential buyers and insider market knowledge.
Where To Sell Vintage Toys #
General Marketplaces:
eBay: A global platform ideal for reaching a wide audience, offering both auction and fixed-price options. eBay
Etsy: Known for vintage and handmade goods, suitable for toys over 20 years old. Etsy
Facebook Marketplace: Useful for local sales without shipping costs, with access to specialised groups. Facebook Marketplace
Gumtree: A local classifieds platform popular in Australia for selling various items, including vintage toys. Gumtree
Collector-Specific Websites:
Sell Your Toys Now: Specialises in buying vintage toys directly from sellers. Sell Your Toys Now
Old Toy Stuff: Focuses on purchasing vintage toys from the 70s, 80s, and 90s. Old Toy Stuff
Vintage Toy Emporium: Buys, sells, and trades vintage and modern toys. Vintage Toy Emporium
Online Auction Sites:
Heritage Auctions: Suitable for high-value or rare vintage toys. Heritage Auctions
Catawiki: A European auction platform popular with collectors of vintage toys. Catawiki
LiveAuctioneers: Hosts auctions for high-end collectibles and toys. LiveAuctioneers
Specialised Forums and Groups:
Reddit: Subreddits like r/ToyExchange or r/ActionFigures allow for direct sales to enthusiasts. Reddit r/ToyExchange
Collector Forums: Platforms like Action Figure Insider offer community forums for buying and selling vintage toys.